Tennessee's African American Lodges: Mount Ararat Cemetery (Benevolent)

Mount Ararat Cemetery in Shelbyville (March 2013)

Back in March, I had the opportunity to slip away to Shelbyville to look for a cemetery associated with the Benevolent Society. Although the conventional wisdom seems to be that benevolent lodges are dead and have no relevance in today's culture, I once again found a cemetery associated with a benevolent group that is in excellent condition. Thanks to field work and seeing some of these cemeteries for myself, I have re-evaluated what I think I know about African American fraternal and benevolent groups.

The cemetery is located on West End Avenue, across from the large cemetery, Willow Mount, used by white citizens in Shelbyville since the 1840s. Once again, the realities of segregated life in Tennessee showed themselves on the landscape - two cemeteries, separated by a fence and a gravel road, one for whites, one for blacks. Despite this separation, they are located adjacent to each other, and both very near the location of Turner Normal School, an African American school opened in the 1880s.

Division between the cemeteries. You can see the fence and road that separate the white cemetery from the black cemetery on the left side of the picture.

Mount Ararat has an association with the Benevolent Society in Shelbyville. There is a large monument to the Benevolent Society in the cemetery, which reads, "Erected to the sacred memory of the honored dead of the Benevolent Society. Their works do follow them. August 1897." Additionally, the cemetery is referenced in the Nashville Globe, an African American newspaper, several times. An article on May 17, 1918 states, "The benevolent order will hold its annual exercises in Mt. Ararat cemetery next Sunday. The speakers are Rev. W.A. Smith, Prof. McAdams, and Rev. E.F. Gooch." Mrs. Lou Emma Tillman, beloved local teacher, is buried in what the Nashville Globe referred to as "the Benevolent Cemetery" in her death notice published July 19, 1918.

Nashville Globe May 28, 1909 blurb stating that Mount Ararat Cemetery is property of the Benevolent Society in Shelbyville.


Monument to the Benevolent Society located in Mount Ararat Cemetery.

As for the cemetery itself, it is unmarked but very well-maintained. There are graveled roads throughout the cemetery, and a large number of trees. There are approximately 400-500 burials, and Find A Grave has them transcribed here. In addition to the Benevolent Society monument, there are other evidences of fraternal groups throughout the cemetery, as several graves have carvings from the Masons, Knights of Pythias, and GUOOF.